Horror Collection
Horror Collectibles, Plushies & Mystery Boxes Shop spooky cute horror merch from...
Horror Collectibles, Plushies & Mystery Boxes Shop spooky cute horror merch from...
Used only if apparel is included. A shirt is not guaranteed.
Couldn't load pickup availability
Love horror merch and a good surprise?
Each Sterye Horror Mystery Box is hand-packed with a varied mix of spooky products, characters, and original designs.
Depending on your box, you may receive:
• Plushies
• Apparel
• Tumblers and drinkware
• Bags and accessories
• Pins and stickers
• Collectibles
• Other spooky surprises
Our boxes pull from different Horror collections, so the items may feature a mix of horror-inspired characters, original Sterye characters, and exclusive (NEVER AI) human designed artwork.
The goal is simple: to make every box feel fun to open, worth the price, and thoughtfully packed with a diverse set of items.
Ordered before?
Leave a note in your cart telling us what you received, and we’ll do our best to avoid duplicates.
Want specific characters?
Leave us a note at checkout and we’ll keep it in mind while packing your box.
⭐ 4.9/5 from 650+ Horror Box reviews
⭐ 4.8/5 from 1,300+ store reviews
Trusted by more than 17,000 customers
Used only if apparel is included. A shirt is not guaranteed.
Couldn't load pickup availability
Current Collection boxes are ready to ship and usually process within up to 3 business days. Next Collection boxes are expected to ship June 10. If your order includes ready-to-ship items, those may ship separately at our normal processing time. Shipping on average takes between 2–5 business days after leaving our warehouse.
No! While we specialize in mystery boxes, we do offer mystery bags, and some items are available for individual purchases aside from boxes!
While we do offer returns within 10 days of the delivery date for most individual items, we currently don't offer returns for mystery boxes or bags. We can still do exchanges for mystery box items if an item is damaged upon delivery. Please notify us within 7 days of the delivery date if an item was damaged. Damaged items would be replaced with the same product that's non-damaged. We do offer returns on individual products if they're ordered outside mystery boxes within 30 days if the product hasn't been used.
Our products change quarterly with different releases and drops. Check out our current mystery box line up under the shop section in our main menu, or home page.
We currently don't offer any subscription services, and all products are one-time purchases.
