Γ

Horror Plushies – Buttoneyes & More – Sterye Mystery Boxes

Γ

Skip to content

Your cart is empty

Continue shopping

Have an account?

Log in to check out faster.

green background with green bag featuring horror buttoneyes characters

Blind Bag Collection

Discover the thrill of surprise with our horror blind bags, each packed...

Blind Bag Collection

Your cart

Loading...

Order special instructions

Order special instructions

Estimated total

$0.00 USD $0.00

Taxes, discounts and shipping calculated at checkout.

Shop
Account
- Rewards
- Account
Community

Country/region

Search

Facebook
Instagram
TikTok

Search

Collection: Plushie Collection

20 products

Filter:

Availability (0)

Availability

In stock (13 products)
Out of stock (7 products)

Price

The highest price is $108.00

$

From

To

Types (0)

Types

Plushies (8 products)

Filter and sort Filter

Filter and sort

Filter

20 products

Availability

In stock (13 products)
Out of stock (7 products)

Clear

Price

The highest price is $108.00

$

From

$

To

Clear

Types

Plushies (8 products)

Clear

Sort by:

Remove all

20 products

Lucibaa the Goat Plushie - EmptyDrop

Sold out

Lucibaa the Goat Plushie

Plushie

Regular price $32.00

Regular price Sale price $32.00 SALE
Unit price per

Sold out
Tear Bear - Horror Valentines Plushie - EmptyDrop

Tear Bear - Horror Valentines Plushie

Regular price $32.00

Regular price Sale price $32.00 SALE
Unit price per
Buttoneyes (The Zombie Bear) Plushie - EmptyDrop

Buttoneyes (The Zombie Bear) Plushie

Plushie

Regular price $32.00

Regular price ~~$28.00~~ Sale price $32.00 SALE
Unit price per
Patchy the Fuzzy pink Bear - EmptyDrop

Patchy the Fuzzy pink Bear

Plushie

Regular price $32.00

Regular price ~~$32.00~~ Sale price $32.00 SALE
Unit price per
Jiggles & Juggles Plushies - EmptyDrop

Jiggles & Juggles Plushies

Regular price $58.00

Regular price Sale price $58.00 SALE
Unit price per
Juggles The Blue Monkey - Horror Valentines - EmptyDrop

Sold out

Juggles The Blue Monkey - Horror Valentines

Regular price $32.00

Regular price Sale price $32.00 SALE
Unit price per

Sold out
Jiggles The Pink Monkey - Horror Valentines - EmptyDrop

Jiggles The Pink Monkey - Horror Valentines

Regular price $32.00

Regular price Sale price $32.00 SALE
Unit price per
Cherux the Devil Cupid - Horror Valentines Plushie (10-inch) - EmptyDrop

Sold out

Cherux the Devil Cupid - Horror Valentines Plushie (10-inch)

Regular price $34.00

Regular price Sale price $34.00 SALE
Unit price per

Sold out
Horror Valentine Plushie Set (All 4 New Plushies) - EmptyDrop

Sold out

Horror Valentine Plushie Set (All 4 New Plushies)

Regular price $108.00

Regular price ~~$128.00~~ Sale price $108.00 SALE
Unit price per

Sold out
Needles the Stitched Rabbit Plushie - EmptyDrop

Needles the Stitched Rabbit Plushie

Plushie

Regular price $32.00

Regular price Sale price $32.00 SALE
Unit price per
Murkwell The Forgotten Sea Creature Plushie - EmptyDrop

Murkwell The Forgotten Sea Creature Plushie

Plushie

Regular price $32.00

Regular price Sale price $32.00 SALE
Unit price per
Cherry Teddy Bear - EmptyDrop

12% OFF

Cherry Teddy Bear

Plushie

Regular price $28.00

Regular price ~~$32.00~~ Sale price $28.00 SALE
Unit price per

1
2

Choosing a selection results in a full page refresh.
Opens in a new window.

Ships in 1–2 Business Days From our Texas warehouse straight to your door.

4.9★ Rated by Horror Fans 1,000+ reviews since 2021 and counting.

Spooky Safe Shipping Guarantee If anything arrives damaged, we replace it.