Halloween Mystery Boxes are Back: The Ultimate Boo Baskets (Boxes!) for 2025 🎃

Halloween Mystery Boxes are Back: The Ultimate Boo Baskets for 2025 🎃

Halloween enthusiasts and Sterye fans: your favorite spooky season treat is just around the corner and we have something extra exciting planned for you! Sterye’s Halloween Mystery Boxes are returning, and they're better (and spookier!) than ever. Mark your calendars, because our Halloween 2025 collection drops on August 14th, and our version of Boo Baskets aka Boo Boxes are sure to sell out fast. Here's what's in store for our Halloween mystery boxes this year.

What's Inside Our Halloween Mystery Box?

Our 2025 Halloween Mystery Box isn't your typical bundle of spooky merch, and it's a bit different than what we did last year. It's an experience in itself with a bunch of exciting items. Each box is carefully curated by our in-house team of Halloween lovers, and filled to the brim with exclusive, high-quality Halloween-themed surprises. This year we decided to combine some of our favorite Halloween elements and movies, and include a mix of Horror to create the perfect Halloween Mystery box.

We'll also have a full on Horror mystery box available for those who dare.. Whether you're gifting to friends, creating your own Halloween traditions, or just treating yourself, these boxes are fantastic Halloween gift ideas. We also have a Halloween mystery bag available at $20, and our own Spooky Halloween Plushie blind bags available as well. Both would make a fun and exciting addition to any of your Spooky Baskets this spooky season.

This year, we’re offering our mystery boxes in three different sizes, ensuring there’s something for every Halloween fan:

🎃 $20 Mystery Bag

• 4 delightfully spooky, smaller-sized items (a $30 value).

👻 $60 Base Halloween Mystery Box

• A $20 mystery bag, a sticker sheet, one collectible blind bag/box item, two exclusive $15 items, and one premium $20+ surprise.

🦇 $95 Premium Halloween Mystery Box (Most Popular!)

• Includes everything from the $60 Base Box, plus a coveted Button-Eyes Halloween Plushie Blind Bag (a $20 value) and either a 40oz tumbler or ultra-soft blanket (valued between $40–$50).

Introducing: Button-Eyes Halloween Plushie Blind Bags!

We’ve leveled up our spooky merch offerings with these must-have Plushie Blind Bags.  Each mystery bag features one of our six exclusive Button-Eyes characters: Original Button Eyes, Patchy the Pink Bear, Howley the Werewolf, Jinxie the Jester, Vampy the Vampire, or fan-favorite Lucibaa the Sacrificed Goat. And the best part? Each plushie includes an easy-to-use attachment, so you can clip them onto bags, backpacks, or keychains. Making them the ultimate Halloween gift ideas for plushie lovers and collectors alike! They'll make a super fun gift this spooky season.

Why Choose Our Halloween Mystery Boxes?

If you've ever searched online for Halloween gift ideas or spooky merch, you know it's tough to find truly original, high-quality items, that you can't get anywhere else. Where the excitement and anticipation of opening the box is matched with the excitement of the actual items you receive inside. Our Halloween Mystery boxes (our version of boo baskets) solve that problem, offering unique, curated collections rather than generic Halloween goods. Focusing on quality, desirability, and most of all fun useful items. Sterye’s boxes feature exclusive artist-designed collectibles you simply can't find elsewhere.

Each box provides the thrill of mystery paired with the certainty of quality. This will be our 5th Halloween of doing mystery boxes, and we want to make it the most exciting. Along with our Halloween drop on August 14th, we'll be doing a mystery drop in October.. 

Perfect for Your Halloween Traditions & Boo Baskets 🎁

Whether you're looking for Halloween gifts for your family, a spooky pick-me-up for a friend, or building the ultimate Boo Basket to surprise your loved ones, our sold separately Halloween items or $20 bags will make a great addition if you aren't looking to purchase a full box. 

Don't Miss Out: Halloween 2025 Is Coming! 🕸️

Halloween shopping starts early, and the most exciting spooky merch sells quickly. Our 2025 Halloween collection launches on Thursday, August 14th at 11am CDT, and supplies are limited. Sign up for our email or SMS alerts now, so you don't miss the Halloween event of the year!

Get ready to be spooked: it's going to be hauntingly good.

We'll see you soon.

Thinking about building a boo basket this spooky season? Check out our guide on how to build the spookiest boo basket this Halloween!