Spooky Season is Coming: Brand New Halloween & Horror Mystery Boxes & Button Eyes Plushie Blind Bags

The Best Halloween Drop of 2025 is Releasing on August 14th

It may still be Summer, but Halloween lovers know it's never too early to gear up for the spookiest season of the year! We're thrilled to announce that our spookiest and biggest drop of the year will be on August 14th, at 11am CDT. We'll have brand new Halloween mystery boxes, Horror mystery boxes, Halloween Plushie Blind Bags, and so much more!

New Button-Eyes Series 2 Characters:

Introducing Count Fang The Vampire, Howley the Beast, Jinxie the Laughing Jester, Knits the Hunter, Zibbit the Chaos Bringer, Bleak the Death Follower, and Gnash the Unextinctable. 

Read more about the current Button-Eyes Characters Here

New Button-Eyes Items

To go along with the new series 2 characters, we'll be introducing them in enamel pin blind bags that'll be in 50% of Horror & Halloween boxes. If a Series 2 Enamel Pin Blind bag isn't in your box, you'll likely get a Howley vs Count Fang Mystery blind box keychain.

Jinxie, Howley, & Count Fang will be potential plushies you can get in our new blind bag plushies. We'll be bringing back Patchy the pink bear, the Original Button Eyes, and the fan favorite: Lucibaa the Sacrificed Goat. to go inside these blind bags. (More info on this below!)

We'll also have a few other Button-Eyes items this drop..

Halloween Mystery Boxes

Our fan-favorite Halloween Mystery Box is back with a wicked twist. Each box is thoughtfully packed with exclusive items designed in-house, ranging from creepy-cute accessories and collectibles to our new Button Eyes Halloween Plushies. The Halloween mystery boxes this year will have 3 different sizes, and the items inside will be a mix of classic Halloween favorites, exclusive Horror merch, and new Button-Eyes items. We have over 15 new Halloween items coming this drop.

Button Eyes Halloween Mini Plushie Blind Bags

Speaking of plushies, our Button Eyes Halloween Mini Plushie Blind Bags are your newest favorite item, and there will be 1 bag in each Horror and Halloween mystery box. We made each smaller versions of a few fan favorite plushies, and introduced a few new ones. Each blind bag contains 1 of 6 of our new Button-Eyes 6-inch plushies, carefully hidden until the moment you tear it open. Will you find the Original Button Eyes, Patchy the Pink bear, Howley the Werewolf, Jinxie the Jester, Count Fang the Vampire, or the favorite: Lucibaa the Sacrificed Goat. Each of our Button Eyes Halloween Edition Plushies will also have an attachment for bags, keychains, or backpacks, so you can take them everywhere you go.

Horror Mystery Boxes

Back to our roots with a brand new Horror collection just for our Horror mystery boxes. A new tumbler, blanket, apparel, Button-Eyes characters, and so much more. We'll have 3 different sizes, and the Horror mystery boxes will strictly be horror merch and Button-Eyes characters. We have over 20 new Horror items coming this drop..

Sizes for Horror and Halloween Mystery Boxes:

$20 Mystery Bag

• Includes 4 Smaller Halloween Items in a mystery bag, great for gifting or building spooky baskets/Boo Baskets ($30 Value)

$60 Base Box

• Includes a $20 mystery bag,1 Collectible Blind Bag/Box, a sticker sheet,  2 $15 items, and 1 $20+ item. ($95 Value)

$95 Ultimate Box + Free Shipping

• Includes a $60 Base Box + Plushie Blind Bag ($20 Value) + 40oz Tumbler or Blanket ($40-$50 Value) Total Value ($150)

Getting Ready for Halloween..

Whether you're looking to get into the spooky season early, or wanting to build a Spooky basket /  Boo Basket with some of our Halloween merch, this Halloween will be awesome! We'll also have lots of items available separately in limited quantities: Like our Button Eyes Halloween plushie blind bags. Pufflegs the spider will also be restocked thanks to all the requests for him!

Can't wait for Halloween? Our current Horror mystery box is still available!

The Sterye Team

P.S. Are you building a boo basket or spooky basket this Halloween season? We consider ourselves somewhat experts on doing these types of things. Feel free to check our guide out on how to build the ultimate boo basket this spooky season!