Γ
Horror Mystery Boxes & Spooky Gift Boxes | Sterye – Sterye Mystery Boxes Skip to content

Your cart is empty

Continue shopping

Have an account?

Log in to check out faster.

Horror Collection

Horror Collection

Horror Collectibles, Plushies & Mystery Boxes Shop spooky cute horror merch from... 

Horror Collection

Your cart

Loading...

Estimated total

$0.00 USD

Taxes, discounts and shipping calculated at checkout.
Add order instructions

CREEPMAS + BLACK FRIDAY IS HERE · Shop now

Menu
Creepmas↗Shop all↗Mystery boxes↗Plushies↗ButtonEyes™↗Horror↗Under $30↗ Our characters Contact us Account
Sterye Mystery Boxes
Need a hand? Cart
CreepmasShop allMystery boxesPlushiesButtonEyes™HorrorUnder $30 Our characters ↗
Home/Mystery boxes & bundles

Mystery boxes & bundles

Find a spooky surprise for yourself, or a whole box of things they’ll love.

★★★★★4.8/5 from 1,473+ reviews

Shop allMystery boxesPlushiesButtonEyes™HorrorHalloweenUnder $30

13 products

Creepmas Box + Krampus Box Bundle (Ships late Nov.)

Creepmas Box + Krampus Box Bundle (Ships late Nov.)

$164.00

Choose options↗
The Krampus Box Bundle — 2026 (Ships Late November)

The Krampus Box Bundle — 2026 (Ships Late November)

$89.00

Choose options↗
The Creepmas Collection Box — 2026 (Ships Late November)

The Creepmas Collection Box — 2026 (Ships Late November)

$75.00

Choose options↗
horror mystery box with 3 different sizes

The Horror Mystery Box

From $45.00

Choose options↗
Sterye's Creepy Carnival poster featuring a creepy clown-like character standing in front of vintage circus tents and red curtains, with large marquee-style text reading 'STERYE'S CREEPY CARNIVAL'.

Creepy Carnival Box

$67.00

View details↗
An orange Halloween-themed subscription box labeled 'THE BOO BOX' with ghost, bat, and skull illustrations, photographed on a dark purple textured background.

The Boo Box

$102.60

View details↗
Six spooky Buttoneyes stitched plush toys in various colors and designs are arranged in front of and on top of mystery blind box packages. The top logo reads 'Buttoneyes"

ButtonEyes Plushie Blind Box

From $27.00

Choose options↗
Gift set with red beanie, tumbler, and other items in a pink box.

The Cherry Gift Box

From $58.00

Choose options↗
The Cottage Box - Sterye Mystery Boxes Sold out

The Cottage Box (New Box coming TBD..)

$60.00

View details↗
Strawberry Cow Milk Carton

Strawberry Cow Milk Carton

$10.00

Choose options↗
Overstock Mystery Box Sold out

Overstock Mystery Box

$21.50

View details↗
mystery bag with 2-4 small mystery items

Mystery Bag (2-4 small mystery Items)

$15.00

View details↗
Underwater scene with a diver and 'Sterye's Spooky Seas' text in a spooky font. Sold out

Spooky Seas Box

$72.50

View details↗

Enter
Invalid Password

STERYE®

Original spooky goodies, mystery boxes, plushies and collectibles for people who never really got over Halloween.

STERYE is a federally registered trademark of Sterye Mystery Boxes, LLC.

Follow the spooky side

New drops, characters and behind-the-scenes chaos.

  • Facebook
  • Instagram
  • TikTok
Payment methods
  • Amazon
  • American Express
  • Apple Pay
  • Bancontact
  • Diners Club
  • Discover
  • Google Pay
  • iDEAL Wero
  • Mastercard
  • PayPal
  • Satispay
  • Shop Pay
  • Visa
Copyright © 2026, Sterye Mystery Boxes. All rights reserved.
  • Start a Claim
  • Refund policy
  • Privacy policy
  • Terms of service
  • Shipping policy
  • Contact information
  • Legal notice
  • Cancellation policy

EARLY BLACK FRIDAY

A little extra, on us.

Spooky Stationery Gift Set - Ships late November

Stationery Gift Set

Retail value: $30

Mystery Plushie Gift Box - Ships late November

Plushie Gift Box

Retail value: $50

Spooky Blanket Box - Ships late November

Spooky Blanket Box

Retail value: $89

One free gift per order at the highest qualifying tier. A higher-tier gift replaces the previous gift. Gifts are automatically added while supplies last.

Shop Creepmas

  • Choosing a selection results in a full page refresh.
  • Opens in a new window.