The Horror Mystery Box

Looking for spooky awesome Horror merch you won't find anywhere else? From exclusive designs & collectibles, limited edition items, and original characters. Come see why Horror fans think our Horror mystery boxes are the best on the market.

Spooky Safe Shipping Guarantee 👻

Your order is protected from porch pirates, ghosts, and gremlins.

Choose Your Box Size

👻 The Base Box – $60

Includes 8–10 total items:

• 1 Horror Bag (4–5 items)

• 1–3 premium items ($15+ value each)

• 1 Blind Bag or Blind Box collectible

• 1-2 featured item ($20+ value)

💰 Total retail value: $90+

🔪 The Ultimate Box – $90

🔥 Best Value! Includes 10–12 total items:

• 1 Horror Bag (4-5 Items)

• 2-3 Premium items ($15+ value each)
• 1 Blind Bag or Blind Box collectible 
• 1-2 Featured items ($20 value)

• PLUS 1-2 Ultimate Items:

  • 1 Woven Blanket ($60 Value) or

  • 1 40oz Tumbler ($45 Value) or

  • 1 24oz Tumbler + T-Shirt ($50 Value)

💰 Total retail value: $150+

Over 1000 5-Star reviews for Sterye boxes since 2021

Come see why thousands of customers love our Horror boxes. We do 3-4 different Horror collections a year, and this one would feature items from all of our past collections. Our next Collection is Creepmas and it'll be dropping on 11/27!

Pick your size and unbox a haunting surprise curated for real horror lovers. (Rather our Halloween mystery box? Click Here.) Want a specific item shown in the example boxes to be included? Leave a note at the cart page, or check if we have it available separately from boxes!

Ordered before and back for another? Leave a note at the cart page with items you received in your 1st box and we'll avoid duplicates!