1 7

ButtonEyes Plushie Blind bags (Ready to Ship)

ButtonEyes Plushie Blind bags (Ready to Ship)

Sterye Mystery Boxes

$20.00
$20.00 SALE
Sale Sold out
  • Spooky Safe Shipping Guarantee

Description

Your new favorite Halloween companion! Each Halloween blind bag contains one random plushie from our growing family of Button-Eyes characters, our original line of haunted, forgotten, and re-stitched stuffed characters, each with their own twisted tale.

This Plushie Blind Bag drop includes:

  • 🦇 Count Fang the Bloodsucker – Count Fang has a thirst for revenge, and hates Howley

  • 🐺 Howley the Beast – Howley hates full moons, and wants to make sure Count Fang never gets stitched back together again.

  • 🎪 Jinxie the Laughing Jester – A carnival reject who laughs even when it hurts.

  • 🧵 Patchy the Pink Bear – The neglected twin of ButtonEyes who's fur turned pink out of desperation to be loved.

  • 🐐 Lucibaa the Sacrificed Goat – A fan favorite, Lucibaa was sacrificed but everything went wrong..

  • 🧸 Buttoneyes The Original Green Bear – The stitched-up leader of them all, and the creator of the stitched army

Each plush is sealed in a mystery blind bag where you won’t know which character you’ll get until you open it. Each character only has 400 made, and there's a 1/6 chance of a specific one being in your bag!

Why a Buttoneyes plushie?

  • High quality detail and stitching
  • Tag with keychain attachment to go on your favorite bags, backpacks, keychains, or wherever you want to put this spooky companion.
  • 6-inch sized plushies make them the CUTEST
  • Unique Backstory and Lore with a dedicated webpage coming soon to this expanding universe!

📦 Shipping & Guarantee

Your order’s protected from porch pirates, ghosts, and gremlins. 👻

We ship spooky fast from Texas!

  • Processing time: up to 3 business days for ready-to-ship items.
  • Delivery time: typically 2–6 business days via USPS or UPS.
  • Priority shipping: arrives in 1–3 business days.

💀 Spooky Safe Shipping Guarantee:

If your order is lost, stolen, or damaged, we’ll send a replacement free of charge.

Need an update or help with an order?

Message us through our website chat or email mystery@sterye.com — we’re quick to respond!

Return Policy

While we do offer returns within 30 days of the delivery date for most individual items, we currently don't offer returns for mystery boxes or any mystery items. We can still do exchanges for mystery box items if an item is damaged upon delivery. Please notify us within 7 days of the delivery date if an item was damaged. Damaged items would be replaced with the same product that's non-damaged. We do offer returns on individual products if they're ordered outside mystery boxes within 30 days if the product hasn't been used.

Reviews

ButtonEyes Plushie Blind bags (Ready to Ship)

ButtonEyes Plushie Blind bags (Ready to Ship)

Sterye Mystery Boxes

$20.00
$20.00 SALE
Sale Sold out
  • Spooky Safe Shipping Guarantee
Packs
View full details

Halloween 2025 Collection

View all

FAQs

What's your shipping + processing time?

Our current processing time is up to 3 business days for ready to ship products. Shipping on average takes between 2-5 business days. If you ever need an order update, or there's an issue with shipping, send us a message through our website's quick chat, or email us at mystery@sterye.com :)

Do you only sell mystery boxes?

No! While we specialize in mystery boxes, we do offer mystery bags, blind bags, and some items are available for individual purchases aside from boxes!

Do you offer returns or exchanges?

While we do offer returns within 30 days of the delivery date for most individual items, we currently don't offer returns for mystery boxes or bags. We can still do exchanges for mystery box items if an item is damaged upon delivery. Please notify us within 7 days of the delivery date if an item was damaged. Damaged items would be replaced with the same product that's non-damaged. We do offer returns on individual products if they're ordered outside mystery boxes within 30 days if the product hasn't been used.

What mystery boxes do you currently offer?

Our products change quarterly with different releases and drops. Check out our current mystery box line up under the shop section in our main menu, or home page.

How do I manage my subscription?

We currently don't offer any subscription services, and all products are one-time purchases.

How often do you release new collections?

We release between 3-5 new collections each year. With at least 3 of them being part of our Horror collection. For 2025, we have a Creepmas box drop and Cherry Box dropping in late November. In 2026, we have our Horror valentine collection dropping in early January, and a Cottage box scheduled for March.