Sterye Mystery Boxes
5 Unique Enamel Pins • 1 Rare Glow-in-the-Dark Chase
Welcome to our original series of Horror with our Button Eyes collection. These are all original characters that we are slowly working on stories and backgrounds, and expanding the Button Eyes universe 1 design and 1 drop at a time.
Button Eyes the Original – Once loved, then discarded, Button Eyes was left to rot. Stitched together with care, and then discarded without a second thought. His Button Eyes wept black tears, his stuffing turned cold. Now he wanders with a knife in hand recruiting other abandoned plushies and giving them their Button Eyes.
Lucibaa the Sacrificed Goat– Marked for sacrifice, Lucibaa was meant to be an offering, but something went wrong. The ritual never finished, leaving them trapped between the living and the damned. Their red-stained fur burns with an unholy presence, and the skull on their forehead whispers secrets only they can hear.
Murkwell The Forgotten Sea Creature – Born in the murky depths, Murkwell was never meant to be loved, only feared. Hidden away, forgotten, and left to rot, he lurks in the Shadows waiting for the world that rejected him to make a mistake.
Needles the Stitched Rabbit – A test subject for endless toy designs, Needles has been cut open, repainted, and rearranged more times than they can remember.
Howley – The rare mystery Button-Eyes that has a component that glows in the dark. Not much is known about him yet, until you unlock him..
Only 1 in every 10 bags contains Howley!
💼 1 enamel pin per blind bag (sealed for surprise!)
✨ Premium hard enamel with black nickel plating
📏 Size: approx. 1.5"–2"
🖼️ Includes collectible info card, a backer card + rubber clutches
🎨 100% designed in-house by Sterye
We use USPS or UPS ground for most deliveries. You can expect your package within 2–6 business days after it leaves our warehouse (Priority is 1–3 business days).
Orders are typically processed and shipped within up to 2 business days. For more info, visit our Delivery & Returns page.
Sterye Mystery Boxes
Couldn't load pickup availability
Our current processing time is up to 3 business days for ready to ship products. Shipping on average takes between 2-5 business days. If you ever need an order update, or there's an issue with shipping, send us a message through our website's quick chat, or email us at mystery@sterye.com :)
No! While we specialize in mystery boxes, we do offer mystery bags, blind bags, and some items are available for individual purchases aside from boxes!
While we do offer returns within 30 days of the delivery date for most individual items, we currently don't offer returns for mystery boxes or bags. We can still do exchanges for mystery box items if an item is damaged upon delivery. Please notify us within 7 days of the delivery date if an item was damaged. Damaged items would be replaced with the same product that's non-damaged. We do offer returns on individual products if they're ordered outside mystery boxes within 30 days if the product hasn't been used.
Our products change quarterly with different releases and drops. Check out our current mystery box line up under the shop section in our main menu, or home page.
We currently don't offer any subscription services, and all products are one-time purchases.
We release between 3-5 new collections each year. With at least 3 of them being part of our Horror collection. For 2025, we have a Creepmas box drop and Cherry Box dropping in late November. In 2026, we have our Horror valentine collection dropping in early January, and a Cottage box scheduled for March.
