Blind Bag Collection
Discover the thrill of surprise with our horror blind bags, each packed...
Discover the thrill of surprise with our horror blind bags, each packed...
Sterye Mystery Boxes
The Horror Essentials Box Bundle brings together the most-loved items from our 2025 May Horror Box, delivering over $130 in value with exclusively designed, creepy-cool merch you won’t find anywhere else. Curated for true horror lovers, this bundle features a mix of collectibles, apparel, décor, and lore-driven pieces inspired by classic slashers, aquatic horror, and the Button Eyes universe.
Inside you'll receive:
• Murkwell or Needles Plushie ($28 value)
• “Swim Risk” Large Tote Bag ($30 value) – double-sided, horror design
• “I Survived Crystal Lake” Hat ($20 value) – slasher vibes, adjustable fit
• Fear Reels Horror Movie Logbook ($20 value) – track 60 scary movies
• Mug + Coaster Set ($20 value) – Alien-inspired and engraved
• Button-Eyes Enamel Pin Blind Bag ($12 value) – 1 of 5 limited pins
• 1 Weatherproof Horror Decal Sticker or sticker sheet ($6-8 value)
Perfect for gifting or building your horror collection, this bundle offers a premium mix of functional, display-worthy, and collectible items. Want just one piece? Each item is also sold individually while supplies last.
*Now Ships in a Kraft box with Horror tissue paper as we've sold out of our Horror box mailers.
Sterye Mystery Boxes
Couldn't load pickup availability
Summer Horror Boxes are currently shipping out within 1-2 business days :)
We ship via USPS or UPS Ground depending on the location for ground shipments. For Priority, we ship via USPS priority, UPS 2-3 Day select. Ground Shipping takes between 2-6 Business Days, and Priority takes between 1-3 Business Days.
🛡️ Satisfaction Guarantee & Easy Returns
100% Risk-Free Purchase: we have you covered.
• Mystery Boxes/Collection Boxes: Final sale unless an item inside arrives damaged or defective. Report damage within 7 days (photo + order #) for a free replacement or store credit.
• Other Products: 14-day satisfaction guarantee. Return unused items in original packaging (proof of purchase required) for hassle-free approval.
• Quick Cancellations: Orders can be cancelled by contacting us as long as they have not been shipped.
• Fast Refunds: Processed within 1-3 business days after approval.
• International Orders: Final sale unless defective on arrival.
Questions or returns? Email us anytime at Mystery@Sterye.com your satisfaction is our top priority!
We’re a tiny team of three bringing you new and exciting items and collections since 2021
Our 1st drop was on Sept 15th, 2021, and it was a Halloween mystery box. We love spooky stuff, and we love bringing you items and designs we find exciting!
All items are hand-designed by us or illustrated by small artists we love. Once items sell out, they’re gone for good—we rarely restock!
Every order keeps our dream alive and funds new boxes and collections.
Thanks for supporting us! ❤️
(Questions? Chat with us via our website chat or email anytime.)
